SCIM and SAML are both essential protocols in identity and access management, but they serve fundamentally different purposes. Whie SCIM handles user provisioning and lifecycle management, SAML focuses on authentication and single sign-on.
Understanding when to use each protocol (and why you often need both) is critical for building secure, enterprise-ready authentication systems. We'll break down what SCIM and SAML do, how they differ, and how they work together to create seamless identity management.
What is SAML?
SAML (Security Assertion Markup Language) is an XML-based protocol used for exchanging authentication and authorization data between an identity provider (IdP) and a service provider (SP). SAML enables single sign-on (SSO), allowing users to authenticate once with their identity provider and then access multiple applications without re-entering credentials.
When a user tries to access an application, the service provider redirects them to their identity provider for authentication. The IdP verifies the user's credentials and generates a SAML assertion, which is a structured XML document containing user details, authentication information, and a digital signature to prevent tampering. The IdP sends this assertion back to the application, which validates it and grants access if valid.
SAML answers the question: "Are you really who you say you are?" It verifies identity and securely opens the door to applications a user is authorized to access.
How SAML Works
The SAML authentication flow typically follows these steps:
A user attempts to access an application (service provider)
The application redirects the user to their identity provider
The user logs into the IdP with their credentials
The IdP generates a SAML assertion containing user details, authentication data, and a digital signature
The IdP sends the assertion back to the application
The application validates the assertion and creates a user session
SAML has been widely adopted for over 20 years and is supported by nearly every identity provider and SSO solution. It's particularly useful when enterprise customers want their employees to log in once and access multiple services seamlessly.
What is SCIM?
SCIM (System for Cross-domain Identity Management) is an open standard protocol designed to automate user provisioning and deprovisioning across different systems and domains. SCIM enables identity providers like Okta, Microsoft Entra ID, or OneLogin to communicate user data to service providers with minimal manual intervention.
SCIM is a RESTful protocol that synchronizes user data efficiently. It exposes two main resources: Users (storing identity and profile information) and Groups (defining access groups and authorization levels). User data is stored as name/value pairs in JSON objects, similar to any REST API.
SCIM answers the question: "Should you have access to this system?" It handles the provisioning step behind the scenes so that authentication via SAML can succeed.
How SCIM Works
When a user is provisioned onto an application, the identity provider exchanges key attributes like the user's name, a stable unique identifier, and email address. This identifier remains unchanged throughout the user's lifetime. Similar data is exchanged during updates or deprovisioning (removal).
Unlike Just-In-Time (JIT) provisioning, which only creates accounts during login, SCIM is proactive. It handles everything ahead of time, making it perfect for IT teams managing many users who need to bulk-provision people or automatically onboard and offboard employees.
SCIM vs SAML: Key Differences
While both protocols play important roles in identity and access management, they serve distinct purposes:
Purpose: SAML is primarily used for authentication and authorization, enabling single sign-on. SCIM is used for automating user provisioning and deprovisioning across systems.
When they act: SAML operates at the time of login, handling authentication duties. SCIM works continuously in the background, syncing user data whenever changes occur in the identity provider.
Data format: SAML uses XML-based assertions with digital signatures. SCIM uses RESTful APIs with JSON data structures.
What they solve: SAML eliminates repeated logins and enables SSO across multiple applications. SCIM ensures users always have correct accounts and permissions based on their role and group membership.
Technical approach: SAML is an XML-based protocol finalized in 2005, requiring careful handling of signatures and assertions. SCIM is a modern RESTful protocol that's easier to implement and integrate.
Why You Need Both SCIM and SAML
SAML and SCIM are not competing standards. They're complementary protocols that work together to create enterprise-ready authentication and provisioning systems.
SAML handles everything that happens at login time, providing secure authentication and SSO capabilities. However, SAML by itself usually isn't enough for secure provisioning. SAML assertions are only passed to your application during login events, which means a user can log in and then have their authorizations revoked by their IT admin without your application knowing about it.
This creates serious security implications. For example, if a customer needs to urgently remove a compromised user account, they can revoke access at their identity provider level, but that user would still have access to sensitive data for the duration of their session, which could be hours or days old.
How SCIM Solves Real-Time Provisioning
SCIM solves this problem by reflecting changes as quickly as the identity provider syncs updates to service providers. Whenever a user requests access to a resource or takes action during a session, you have reliable, up-to-date authorization data available to decide whether access should be granted. Once you receive a deprovisioning event, you can immediately end a user's active session.
Think of it this way: SAML can authenticate a user to an application, but if that user's account was never provisioned in the app, they still won't get in. SCIM handles that provisioning step behind the scenes so authentication via SAML can succeed.
When to Use SAML vs SCIM
The choice between SAML and SCIM isn't always yours to make. If your prospective customer's IT team is heavily invested in using a SCIM-powered directory solution to manage access across their infrastructure, they'll likely mandate that you support SCIM. Otherwise, they might choose a SCIM-equipped competitor instead.
Use SAML when:
You need to enable single sign-on for enterprise customers
Users should authenticate once and access multiple applications
You want to enforce consistent authentication policies across platforms
Your customers require SSO integration with their identity provider
Use SCIM when:
You need real-time synchronization of user data across systems
Automated user provisioning and deprovisioning is critical for security
Your customers manage large numbers of users who need bulk provisioning
You want to ensure users are immediately removed when they leave an organization
You need up-to-date authorization data for access control decisions
Use both when:
Building enterprise-grade authentication systems
Your customers require comprehensive identity lifecycle management
Security and compliance demand real-time access revocation
You want to provide the best user experience with automated provisioning and SSO
Security Considerations
When implementing SAML and SCIM together, keep these security considerations in mind:
Session management with SAML. Since SAML assertions are only passed during login, sessions can become outdated. Implement session timeout policies and consider re-authentication for sensitive actions.
Real-time deprovisioning with SCIM. SCIM enables immediate access revocation. When you receive a deprovisioning event, end the user's active session immediately to prevent unauthorized access.
Signature validation. SAML requires proper validation of digital signatures on both the response and every assertion. Failing to validate signatures creates serious security vulnerabilities.
Webhook reliability. SCIM provisioning updates can arrive out-of-sequence, delayed, or fail to arrive. Implement proper error handling and reconciliation processes to catch missed updates.
Attribute mapping. Identity providers often use attributes differently or rely on custom attributes. Build flexible attribute mapping to handle variations across different IdPs.
Implementation Challenges
Both SAML and SCIM can be implemented manually as open standards, but there are several challenges to consider:
SAML complexity
SAML is an XML-based protocol with strict syntax requirements and a comprehensive specification covering numerous protocols, bindings, and digital signatures. This creates a steep learning curve compared to modern REST APIs.
SCIM variations
While SCIM is well-defined, individual identity providers often implement it slightly differently. They may treat suspended users differently, use attributes in unique ways, or rely heavily on custom attributes requiring custom implementations.
Ongoing maintenance
Both protocols require ongoing maintenance as identity providers update their implementations. You'll need to test against multiple IdPs and handle edge cases specific to each provider.
Security requirements
Properly implementing these protocols requires deep security expertise. You must validate signatures, handle encryption, prevent replay attacks, and secure sensitive user data.
The Bottom Line
SAML and SAML work together to provide comprehensive identity and access management. SAML handles authentication and enables single sign-on, while SCIM automates user provisioning and ensures real-time synchronization of user data across systems.
Together, these protocols reduce friction for both users and IT teams. SAML eliminates repeated logins, while SCIM ensures users always have the correct accounts and permissions based on their group membership and role changes. This combination results in a more secure, automated, and predictable access experience across your organization.
For enterprise-ready applications, implementing both SCIM and SAML isn't just a best practice. It's often a requirement from customers who need secure, scalable identity management that protects their users and resources while delivering excellent user experiences.
Enter our orbit.
